I devoured Judy Blume books as a child. I can’t remember exactly how many of her books that I’ve read, but looking at the list, I’m guessing 14. From that number alone, I would consider her to be one of the most prolific authors of my adolescence. Blume’s books are known to tackle real subjects that tweens face, such as navigating friendships, puberty, bullying, body changes, and more. Several of her books have been mainstays on banned lists for decades, because she writes about (important) topics such as menstruation, masturbation, body image, birth control, and sex.
I don’t remember the specifics of many of the books that I’ve read, but I do remember reading “Are you There God? It’s Me, Margaret.” When the movie adaptation was released in 2023, my mom and I saw it in theaters. I recently decided to revisit both. I think the book holds up as a beautiful coming-of-age story for adolescent girls, and the movie does a wonderful job of staying true to the book. I think either medium would be a great tool for any 10-14ish year-old, especially one that will be experiencing menstruation, buying a bra for the first time, and other experiences of puberty. I’m not going to use the rest of this post as a review or a summary, but more so as a reflection of some of the aspects of the overall story and how the movie portrayed the plot point.
The Puberty of it all: One of the major themes throughout the book, and one of the main reasons why I think it’s such an important read for young people, is Margaret’s journey into puberty. Buying a bra, praying and chanting for chest growth (who could forget “We must, we must, we must increase our bust!”), waiting for the first menstrual cycle, buying deodorant… I had forgotten just how BIG all of these moments felt, but this book and movie transport me right back. Blume and the filmmakers are able to portray these moments in a sensitive and honest way. Puberty is confusing, scary, and stigmatized (see: book bans) and I believe this story can help tweens feel seen and less alone.
Religion: The other major plot line running through the book is Margaret’s grappling with religiosity. With a Jewish dad and a Christian mom who was disowned by her parents due to marrying someone Jewish, Margaret’s parents have decided to raise Margaret without a religious tradition. Throughout the book, Margaret prays to God (she thinks, maybe), sometimes hilariously, like when praying for her chest to grow, and often tenderly. She spends the book exploring faiths, looking for God in different church services, but only ever feeling God when she is alone. Something I love about this storyline is that it doesn’t end wrapped in a bow. At the end of the book, Margaret remains confused about religion. She even abandons talking to God at one point, finding her way back by the end.
Changing bodies: There’s a character in the story named Laura Danker who has developed at a younger age than the rest of the girls in Margaret’s class, and is taller than all of the boys. Rumors circulate around Laura that she is much more sexually experienced than the rest of the girls, and she is bullied and picked on by her classmates. I did not remember this storyline and was pleased by its inclusion and nuance. Sexualization of girls and women is a huge problem in our society, and many women can remember the first time they were sexually harassed, often in their young teens. I think Blume was able to touch on this subject in an age-appropriate manner, while also reminding girls that it can be hard to be the one that goes through puberty first.
Other things about the movie specifically that I loved: I enjoyed both my reread and rewatch of the movie, but the movie especially feels like a warm hug. It brought the book to life so beautifully, and felt both timeless and nostalgic. Here are some random things that I appreciated about the movie:
- The actors: Rachel McAdams and Kathy Bates are just amazing, and Abby Ryder Fortson, who played Margaret, gave such an earnest performance
- The early 1970s soundtrack and fashion
- The expanded storyline of Barbara, Margaret’s mom. In the movie, Barbara is trying to reinvent herself, quitting her job and trying to fit the mold of a suburban mom. She joins every committee in the PTA and is miserable. At the end of the movie she’s back to teaching art classes and quits the PTA.
- The blink-and-you-miss-it cameo by Queen Judy herself
This reread and rewatch were a delight for me, and I think stories like Margaret are immensely important for young people to have at their disposal.




